The Case of the Missing Bees

by Anne Sherrod

According to the Canadian Association of Profes­sional Apriculturalists, Canada lost 29 per cent of its honeybees last winter. The previous aver­age national loss was 15 per cent. There have been many claims in Canada that these losses are not from Colony Collapse Disorder (CCD), the mysterious malady that wiped out tens of billions of bees in the US last winter. However, some Canadian beekeepers have reported losses on the order of 50-80 per cent, and some of them say they are seeing symptoms of CCD.

Whatever the cause, CCD is just one catastrophe among many that have been hitting commercial and wild bee populations since the late 1980s.

They are all part of a long-term decline of domestic and wild pollinators (such organisms as bees, birds, bats and butterflies) around the world.

In North America it began when imported honeybees brought non-native diseases that decimated commercial and wild bee populations. Commercial beekeeping also led to unnatural practices to boost honey production and pol­lination services for crop growers. For many years conven­tional beekeeping has relied heavily upon the use of chemi­cals and antibiotics to kill various disease agents. Now the organisms that prey on bees are increasingly resistant to these treatments, while bees are showing alarming signs of immune deficiency.

That being said, the particular symptoms that charac­terize CCD are relatively new, especially the fact that the bees just disappear rather than dying near their hives. Con­cerns about genetically-modified (GM) crops have been discounted by some scientists but not by others. There have been massive losses of bees in Europe and other parts of the world that have very little land planted in GM crops.

However, such arguments may fail to address the full scope of the risks of GM crops. Recently, Professor Hans-Hinrich Kaatz of the University of Jena in Germany discov­ered that the gene inserted in oilseed rape had transferred into bacteria in the intestines of young bees (Guardian, May 28, 2007.)

Intestinal bacteria play important roles in the health of the organisms they colonize. Any change in their genetic structure could, under the right con­ditions, reproduce itself rapidly and have serious consequences for the bees (and humans too).

Meanwhile, the synthetic insecti­cide imidacloprid and its relatives, the neonicotinoids, continue to be sus­pects in the CCD investigation. These insecticides are high­ly toxic to bees. Recent research has found imidacloprid in corn, sunflower and rape pollen at levels high enough to pose a threat to bees. It impairs their memory, which might explain why the CCD victims disappeared rather than re­turning to their hives.

A preliminary report by the CCD Working Group, a panel of bee experts in the US, states that certain fungi­cides may increase the toxicity of neonicotinoids over 1,000 times in laboratory tests. Both the neonicotinoids and the fungicides are commonly used.

One Canadian beekeeper has pointed out to the Pesti­cide Management Regulatory Agency (PMRA) that corn syrup is fed to commercial honeybee colonies throughout North America. Corn syrup is the concentrated product of a huge amount of corn. What happens to neonicotinoids in the manufacturing process? Has anyone tested corn syrup for contamination?

The PMRA, which writes the permits for the use of imidacloprid, says it has no testing requirements for imi­dacloprid in corn syrup. This is characteristic of much that we do not know about the poisons we pour into the environ­ment every year.

***

Interested? A reading list is posted on the Watershed Sentinel web site. www.watershedsentinel.ca

Anne Sherrod has been writing on environmental issues in BC for 25 years. She is currently Chair of the Valhalla Wilderness Society.

[Watershed Sentinel, May/June, 2007]

Become a supporter of independent media today!

We can’t do it without you. When you support independent reporting, every donation makes a big difference. We’re honoured to accept all contributions, and we use them wisely. Our supporters fund untold stories, new writers, wider distribution of information, and bonus copies to colleges and libraries. Donate $50 or more, and we will publicly thank you in our magazine. Regardless of the amount, we always thank you from the bottom of our hearts.