Canada's New Foreign Aid Supports Mining

by Miranda Holmes

March 22 is World Water Day, established by the UN as a day to contemplate the importance of access to water for life on earth. Just like every other day of the year., on World Water Day, nearly 2000 children around the world will die from diarrhea caused by unsafe water and poor sanitation.

It is almost impossible to overstate the difference access to clean water can make to an impoverished community.

In 2006 I met Haua Musa, a grandmother from Fikayi, a tiny village in Nigeria. Two of her 10 children and four of her 15 grandchildren had died of diarrhea. At the time I was working for a development charity which was digging a well for her village to replace their only existing source of water — a fetid pond. I asked her what the well would mean to her. This is what she told me:

In water-poor countries around the world, Canadian mining companies are sucking up — and poisoning — water desperately needed for agriculture, cooking and basic survival.

“My life has been dominated by water: when I want a drink, there is no water, when I want to cook, there is no water, when I want to bathe, there is no water. I no longer have to collect water myself, my grandchildren do that for me now. But that saddens me, too. I would rather they were in school, but the nearest school is too far away for the children to attend. The village has already decided that once the well is installed and we have latrines built, the next thing we are going to do is to build a school. With water and sanitation we will be able to get a teacher to come, without it, we can’t.”

The school was built, the teacher came, and Haua, a force to be reckoned with, made sure the beneficiaries were both the boys and the girls of the village. She knew, perhaps instinctively, what the United Nations Population Fund has clearly established: the connection between educating girls and reducing poverty.

Something as simple (and cheap) as access to clean water can make a huge difference to the health and well-being of an impoverished community.  Canada devotes only a very a small percentage of GDP to foreign aid (0.31 percent). Therefore, it is dispiriting to learn that Julian Fantino, head of the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) plans to align the agency’s ever-dwindling budget to the interests of the Canadian mining industry.

In 2010, in the run up to the narrow defeat of the Responsible Mining Act (proposed as a Private Member’s Bill), a copy of a report the Prospectors and Developers Association of Canada (PDAC) commissioned — but never released –  was leaked to the Toronto Star. The easily drawn conclusion of the report was that “Canadian mining companies are far and away the worst offenders in environmental, human rights and other abuses around the world.”

In water-poor countries around the world, Canadian mining companies are sucking up — and poisoning — water desperately needed for agriculture, cooking and basic survival. Every year the global mining industry dumps more than 180 million tonnes of hazardous mining waste into the world’s ocean, lakes, rivers and streams. That waste contains dozens of dangerous chemicals, including arsenic, cyanide, lead and mercury.

As Dawn Paley reports in the current issue of Watershed Sentinel, in Oaxaca, southern Mexico, poor people are being driven off their land and deprived of the water they need to grow food by mining companies like Vancouver-based Fortuna Silver. And at least one anti-mining activist has met a sudden, violent death.

A previous report by Paley  highlighted the threats posed to Baja’s fragile aquifer by the proposals of two Canadian companies to mine for gold with cyanide. Costa Rica and many provinces of Argentina have banned mining that uses cyanide to separate the gold from the ore.

Victims of human rights abuses by security forces at a Hudbay Minerals mine in Guatemala are currently seeking redress in a Canadian court. They are unlikely to succeed.  Canadian courts have already ruled against claimants from Ecuador (Copper Mesa Mining Corp) and the Congo (Anvil Mining).

Elsewhere, Barrick Gold has been vilified for offering counseling and health care to women gang raped by security men at their Papua New Guinea mine only after they agreed to sign away all rights to prosecute the company and Human Rights Watch has accused Nevsun Resources of using forced labour in the construction of its mine in Eritrea. The list goes on.

Perhaps no one should be surprised that dedicated staff at CIDA are disheartened about being micromanaged and gagged. Many still see it as their responsibility to help Canada fulfill its obligation to meet the Millennium Development Goals to alleviate global poverty, although doing so has not been a Harper government priority.

I wish I could arrange a meeting on World Water Day between Minister Fantino and Haua Musa. If he were to ask her how CIDA should prioritize spending its limited budget in order to improve life in impoverished communities around the globe, I can guarantee helping Canadian mining companies polish their tarnished image would not be on her list.

***

A day after the piece appeared, we received the following letter from the Minister. Two days later, the Harper government announced that it was rolling CIDA into the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade.
A letter from Julian Fantino, Minister of International Cooperation in response to the article by Miranda Holmes can be found HERE

Photo by Miranda Holmes

Watershed Sentinel Original Content

5 Issues/yr — $25 print; $15 digital